Delete non-unique group with group ID as primary group of a user

Question

So say I have two groups with names testing1 and testing2. Both groups have the same group ID of 2000. Then I add a user named testing-user with GID of 2000. Along the way I want to delete group testing2, but I cannot because when I try I get the following response

groupdel: cannot remove the primary group of user 'testing-user'

Here are the methods I have tried around this to success:

Modified testing1's GID and then deleted testing2, then changed testing1's GID back to 2000
Modified testing-user's primary GID to a separate group, deleted testing2 then assigned testing-user to testing1

Is there a better method for this that does not involve modifying the users or group id's in question?

In fact, there's several problem here, first two group with the same GID, second, you're question is in my opinion more about opinion because you create a non logical situation and try to find the "best possible solution"... — Kiwy, Jun 24 '14 at 08:02
On which Unix OS are you doing this ? Are you using locally defined users and groups or some kind of external backend like LDAP or NIS(+) ? — Benoit, Jun 24 '14 at 08:07

Matt · Answer 1 · 2014-07-01T12:11:13.007

2

This is not that safe as you should always use the provided utilities to modify users are groups but...

[ ! -f /etc/group.lock ] && perl -ne 'next if /^testing2:/; print' /etc/group > /etc/group.lock && mv /etc/group.lock /etc/group && grpconv

edited Jul 01 '14 at 12:11

answered Jun 24 '14 at 23:42

Matt

8,991

What about /etc/gshadow? – Cristian Ciupitu Jun 30 '14 at 15:58

score 2 · Accepted Answer · edited Apr 13 '17 at 12:36

The error you're getting is a limitation of the way groupdel was written and the fact that the system is designed around numbers (IDs) and not names. As you can see in source code of groupdel, it only checks if there's a user having the GID you want to delete, as its primary group. It doesn't matter if there's another group having the same ID, but named differently.

/* [ Note: I changed the style of the source code for brevity purposes. ]
 * group_busy - check if this is any user's primary group
 *
 *      group_busy verifies that this group is not the primary group
 *      for any user.  You must remove all users before you remove
 *      the group.
 */
static void group_busy (gid_t gid)
{
        struct passwd *pwd;

        /* Nice slow linear search. */
        setpwent ();
        while ( ((pwd = getpwent ()) != NULL) && (pwd->pw_gid != gid) )
                ;
        endpwent ();

        /* If pwd isn't NULL, it stopped because the gid's matched. */
        if (pwd == (struct passwd *) 0)
                return;

        /* Can't remove the group. */
        fprintf (stderr,
                 _("%s: cannot remove the primary group of user '%s'\n"),
                 Prog, pwd->pw_name);
        exit (E_GROUP_BUSY);
}

So you either you mess with the configuration files using other tools like Perl in mtm's answer or you temporarily change the GID of that user so that group_busy doesn't fail anymore.

score 0 · Answer 3 · answered Jun 24 '14 at 16:52

0

The default group of any user, at least on Gentoo, is to have the group name the same as the user name. If you create a group and put a user in it, when removed, the user will belong to the group of his username.

answered Jun 24 '14 at 16:52

eyoung100

6,252
23
53

Delete non-unique group with group ID as primary group of a user

3 Answers3