Safest way to store environment variable value in a file

Question

I am using bash and most interested in an answer for bash, but you can answer about how to do it in other shells if you want.

I have an environment variable, KEY, and I want to store the value of that environment variable in a a file. Currently I am doing

echo "${KEY}" > ./key.pem

In practice this seems to be OK, but in theory this breaks when KEY=-n.

$ export KEY=-n
$ echo BEGIN "${KEY}" END
BEGIN -n END
$ echo "${KEY}" END
END$

So, is there a better way to store the value of a single environment variable in a file? (Note that export and declare will include the name of the variable in their outputs, which is no good for me.)

What will use the file? Will it be used to set the value again in a shell script, or by some other tool? — muru, Aug 12 '19 at 17:38
@drewbenn echo -- "$KEY" would not help. It would output -- -n. — Kusalananda, Aug 12 '19 at 17:45
@Kusalananda, I'm a bit disappointed that all my shells consistently output -- -n — ilkkachu, Aug 12 '19 at 17:53
This is one of the reasons why printf is always better than echo when you don't have complete control over what input you want to print. — terdon, Aug 12 '19 at 18:12
@ilkkachu Hmm... Usually, consistency is considered a good thing ;-) — Kusalananda, Aug 12 '19 at 18:59
@ilkkachu, the rc clone for Unix and its es/akanga derivatives support echo --. Early versions of zsh did as well, but the end-of-option delimiter later changed to - for consistency with Bourne/Korn shell and builtins I suppose. — Stéphane Chazelas, Aug 13 '19 at 07:22
@StéphaneChazelas, and fish (2.7.1) too. I'm not sure if I should say I'm happy now... — ilkkachu, Aug 13 '19 at 07:32
@ilkkachu, the problem is that POSIX forbids echo from supporting an end-of-option marker. I did ask that zsh's - be allowed but it was rejected. See http://austingroupbugs.net/view.php?id=1222 (linked from the Why is printf better than echo? Q&A) — Stéphane Chazelas, Aug 13 '19 at 07:37

Kusalananda · Accepted Answer · 2019-08-12T20:29:44.553

If it's storing for the sake of reading it in later (in a bash script), just use declare -p KEY and then source the file to read it in again. If you just want to store the value, use printf '%s\n' "$KEY" as you would do when you output any variable data.

So,

printf '%s\n' "$KEY" >key.pem

or

printf 'BEGIN %s END\n' "$KEY" >key.pem

or whatever you need to output.

Your issue occurs since -n is a valid option to echo in bash. The strings -e and -E (and combinations like -neEne) would also cause issues in bash, for the same reason. Depending on how bash is built or the environment or options, backslash characters in arguments may also be a problem.

These issues and more are outlined in the following Q/A:

Why is printf better than echo?

Stéphane Chazelas · Answer 2 · 2019-08-13T07:18:22.097

Many systems have a printenv command that outputs the contents of the given environment variable followed by one newline character to standard output (printenv appeared in 3BSD in the late 70s):

printenv 'My Env Var' > file

Would store the content of the My Env Var variable followed by NL into file in all shells on those systems.

For environment variables that are mapped to shell variables (includes at least those whose name starts with an ASCII letter or underscore and are followed by 0 or more ASCII letters, digits or underscore, and are not otherwise special variables set by the shell), in Bourne-like shells (also works in fish), you can do the same with:

printf '%s\n' "$ENVVAR" > file

(though if the variable is unset, that will still store an empty line into file)

In rc-like shells (where all shell variables are mapped to environment variables):

printf '%s\n' $ENVVAR > file
printf '%s\n' $'My Env Var' > file

(same caveat as above)

In csh-like shells:

printf '%s\n' $ENVVAR:q > file

(if the variable is not set, it will fail and not overwrite file)

Some implementations/versions of ksh don't have printf builtin. In those, you could also do:

print -r -- "$ENVVAR" > file

Safest way to store environment variable value in a file

2 Answers2